I am quite happy with this case. It provides good protection for my Nano 2nd Generation. I am especially impressed that the click wheel is still very responsive under the silicone cover. The opening for the Hold switch is very small but I was able to clip around the opening to allow better access. Of course, this would not be much of an issue if the iPod did not need to be reset after every synch. The clip does seem fragile, as others have noted. It is designed much like a non-clip clothes pin. It works well enough for my needs, but I would not recommend this to someone who wants to use the clip often or to attach to a thick jacket or such.